When facing criminal charges, the stakes couldn’t be higher. Your choice of legal representation can make the difference between a favorable outcome and a life-altering consequence. Yet, too many people make critical mistakes when selecting a criminal defense attorney. Based on my nearly 20 years of experience, both as a prosecutor and as a defense attorney, here are the top three errors to avoid.
1. Hiring a Random Attorney
One of the most common mistakes people make is hiring an attorney who doesn’t focus on criminal defense. Whether it’s your family law attorney or the lawyer who handled your father’s will, these are not the professionals you need when facing criminal charges. You need someone who lives and breathes criminal defense.
The truth is, an attorney who dabbles in criminal law can be more dangerous than helpful. During my time as a deputy prosecutor, I often faced off against attorneys who “did a little criminal law on the side.” These lawyers were easy targets because they lacked the necessary expertise, and their clients paid the price. If your attorney doesn’t regularly practice criminal defense, your chances of a favorable outcome diminish significantly.
2. Choosing an Attorney Without an Office Staff
Another major mistake is hiring a criminal defense attorney who lacks a dedicated office staff. A solo attorney without support may be overwhelmed by administrative tasks, leaving little time to focus on your defense. This can result in poor communication and delayed responses—two things you do not want when your future is on the line.
An attorney with a competent support team, including paralegals and legal assistants, ensures that your case progresses smoothly. These professionals can quickly respond to your inquiries, keep you updated, and handle essential but routine tasks. When your attorney is supported by an efficient team, they can focus on what truly matters—crafting a strong defense strategy.
3. Failing to Research Your Attorney Online
In today’s digital age, there’s no excuse for not thoroughly vetting your attorney online. Don’t just take their word for it—verify their credentials and experience. Look at Google Reviews, Avvo ratings, and other online resources to see what past clients have to say. Make sure the attorney you’re considering has a solid track record in criminal defense, not just in legal practice generally.
Be cautious of attorneys who have recently switched fields. While a lawyer who’s been defending insurance claims for 20 years might be an knowledgable in that area, they may not have the experience needed to handle a criminal case effectively. You don’t want to be their “trial run” in criminal defense.
Why Experience Matters in DUI Defense
DUI charges are a perfect example of why experience matters. Many attorneys see DUI cases as easy money because they involve everyday people who can afford to pay. However, defending a DUI case requires specialized knowledge and skills that go beyond general legal expertise. In Indiana, DUI (or OVWI) cases are complex, with severe penalties that can impact your life for years. An attorney who doesn’t fully understand DUI law could lead you to a poor outcome.
Make the Right Call
The bottom line is this: Your first choice of a criminal defense attorney should be the right one. Don’t hire a lawyer who dabbles in criminal law, lacks a competent support staff, or has a questionable online reputation. If you’re in doubt about your current attorney or have made a mistake in your selection, it’s not too late to make a change. Reach out to an experienced Indiana DUI attorney who knows the ins and outs of criminal defense.
If you or someone you know is facing domestic violence charges reach out to our criminal defense attorneys at The Marc Lopez Law Firm. Call us today at 317-632-3642 and remember—always plead the 5th!
